I know some of you don’t agree, like Deus, but I think that situation is fine. One thing to say if Ortiz shouldn’t be in because he’s a DH but the steroid thing is not the same. Both ARod and Clemens were using well after all of the steroid stuff became highly publicized, and it was extremely clear from the reaction that anyone caught using would be considered tainted.
Ortiz had his name on a list in 2003. Around that time we were still in the shadows of McGuire and Sosa, and not to say that it was OK to be using, but I think people generally got a pass for being on the list then if they weren’t caught again, which Ortiz wasn’t. Of course that wasn’t really upheld consistently given that McGwire and Sosa didn’t get into the hall. But both of them strongly denied it when they were in the spotlight in the late 90s too.
Ortiz kind of got a pass because he continued to play well for another decade and supposedly was clean during that time. Also, the 2003 list was problematic. Bonds and Clemens had way more evidence of long-term use.
I don’t really care that much. This is just my basic take, but I think everyone gives way too much respect to the Hall of Fame in all the sports. It’s just the opinions of people who are generally not very bright so we really should just ignore it and not give it so much reaction and hope it just dies down.